Randy Udall: Taking the Vulcan view of our energy future
Aspen Times Weekly
Back in the 1960s, when NBC was first developing the Star Trek series, a producer fretted that “Spock, the guy with the pointed ears,” would scare every kid in America. Spock, played by Leonard Nimoy, was a humanoid from the planet Vulcan, and Vulcans are what we humans would call hard-hearted. They don’t believe in fairy tales and pixie dust, that Dorothy can click her heels and go home again.
When it comes to energy, the scientist who best exemplifies Vulcan logic is Vaclav Smil. The world’s foremost energy historian, he began a recent essay with this blunt statement: “Our transition away from fossil fuels will take decades — if it happens at all.”
A distinguished professor at the University of Manitoba, Smil finds most American energy discussions maddening. He does not believe that our cars will soon be powered by fuel cells, that clean coal can solve the climate problem or that venture capital will discover an energy analogue to the cellular phone. He calls Al Gore’s proposal to re-power America with renewable energy in a decade “delusional.”
Energy systems are built out of copper and steel and megatons of concrete. Their operating systems don’t change; 60 hertz never goes obsolete. Upgrading power plants is generally unnecessary, except where pollution controls are concerned, and replacing them is expensive, which is why there are hundreds of 40-year-old coal plants. In short, you can throw your laptop out every few years and order a new one, but Hoover Dam will still be plugging the Colorado River centuries from now.
Given climate realities, we desperately need a rapid energy transformation, but wishing can’t make it so. As a Vulcan might say, what is desirable is not necessarily probable. James Watt’s steam engine revolutionized the mining and transportation of coal, but it still took a century for coal to displace wood. Solar photovoltaic cells were invented 55 years ago, and yet today in the United States they produce less electricity than Glen Canyon Dam. Eight years after its introduction, the ingenious Prius has yet to become 1 percent of the automotive fleet.
Like it or not, Smil believes we are captive to past investments, to the multi-trillion-dollar energy networks we have already created, and, above all, to the scale of our energy appetites. Only the last of those factors seems amenable to rapid change, and thus his advice to President Obama: “Explain to the nation that Americans, who consume twice as much energy per capita as rich Europeans (and have nothing to show for it), should try to live within some sensible limits, which means using less fuel not more.”
In his books, Smil explains how prehistoric cultures harvested the energy from sunlight, plants and firewood. In the Southwest, energy shortages were generally caused by drought and expressed as famine. When the Anasazi ran short of protein, they began eating each other: “man corn.”
We have much larger appetites today. Melanie Moses, a biologist at the University of New Mexico, calculates that a typical North American consumes energy at a rate sufficient to sustain a 66,000-pound primate.
That’s a very big ape, and Smil is not the only one asking whether it’s realistic to meet his gargantuan appetite with wind and solar, dilute flows of power that today provide less than 1 percent of U.S. energy. Unlike oil shale – the thermodynamically doomed effort to turn chicken manure into chicken salad – wind, solar and geothermal have high energy returns and a bright future. Nonetheless, it will take many doublings before they will meet a significant percentage of our needs.
Smil can envision running a lightly populated state like Montana or Wyoming on renewables once their fossil fuels run out. Urban areas present a more difficult problem. By abusing a calculator and common sense, one can sketch out a renewable blueprint for a city like Phoenix, but after awhile the numbers begin to seem like so much Hohokam. Phoenix long ago exceeded its carrying capacity and is likely to remain dependent on imported oil, gas and nuclear power, for as long as such things last.
In his personal life, Smil is an avid conservationist, proud of his super-efficient house and frugal Honda. In his recent work, there is a hint of frustration with what he sees as the cannibalization of our host planet. Contemplating our journey to the future, where no man has gone before, he writes, “I am always trying to imagine what would be the verdict of a sapient extraterrestrial informed about the behavior of affluent Earthlings.” Unless saving energy quickly becomes the nation’s focus, we have the answer: “Beam me up, Scotty, there’s no intelligent life down here.”
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
Readers around Aspen and Snowmass Village make the Aspen Times’ work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.
Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.
Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.
Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.
User Legend: Moderator Trusted User