Natural-gas settlement at Roan Plateau announced |

Natural-gas settlement at Roan Plateau announced

A map of the Roan Plateau lease area shows the 17 leases on top that are to be canceled and the two that will remain, along with 12 other leases at the base of the Roan that will also be reinstated.
Courtesy Earth Justice and BLM |

Industry and environmental groups joined federal, state and local officials Friday in applauding a long-anticipated settlement regarding natural-gas development on the Roan Plateau west of Rifle.

The landmark deal protects most of the public lands on top of the Roan from drilling, at least for the foreseeable future, while allowing development to continue on other leases in the area, including those at the base of the Roan.

The settlement was announced Friday afternoon at a joint news conference at the state Capitol by Gov. John Hickenlooper and U.S. Interior Secretary Sally Jewell.

“This is great news for the state of Colorado and for the local community, who have worked hard to strike a balance between protecting open space and energy development,” Jewell said in a formal news release.

“The Roan Plateau is an extraordinary place, and this settlement is a model for what can be accomplished when we all come to the table and work to find solutions,” she said.

Hickenlooper reacted to the Bureau of Land Management, Bill Barrett Corp. and a coalition of environmental groups’ formal release of the statement, saying, “We are thrilled to see resolution for this decade-long controversy over one of Colorado’s most special places. “This settlement will protect the valuable fish and wildlife resources atop the Roan Plateau while clearing the way for orderly development to take place elsewhere in the planning area.”

The agreement cancels 17 of the 19 leases issued on the plateau in 2008 and refunds approximately $47.6 million in bonus bids and annual rental payments to Barrett Corp.

Barrett’s remaining two leases on top of the plateau and 12 leases at the base of the Roan cliffs, which are held by WPX, Ursa and Oxy, will remain in place.

Pete Maysmith, executive director for Conservation Colorado, spoke on behalf of numerous environmental, conservation and recreation groups involved in the lawsuit challenging the BLM’s decision to issue the leases on approximately 55,000 acres of the Roan.

“Conservationists, hunters, anglers and wildlife advocates welcome this settlement and the opportunity it provides to conserve an area rich in wildlife and unparalleled scenic vistas,” Maysmith said. “This settlement helps us achieve the goal of preserving important natural areas, like the Roan Plateau in Colorado, while oil and gas development continues in Colorado and across the West.”

Other groups involved in the settlement included Earthjustice, the Wilderness Society, Rocky Mountain Wild, the Sierra Club, Rock the Earth and the Carbondale-based Wilderness Workshop.

“We thank Gov. Hickenlooper, Rep. (Scott) Tipton and our senators for their support of this balanced plan that offers strong protections for the Roan Plateau while still allowing reasonable access to energy leases,” said Peter Hart, staff attorney for the Wilderness Workshop.

David Ludlam, executive director for the West Slope Colorado Oil and Gas Association, said the compromise will provide many decades’ worth of jobs and needed tax dollars for local communities.

“Today, we celebrate the local governments and tireless elected officials of northwest Colorado who secured responsible drilling on one of western Colorado’s most important energy reserves,” Ludlam said. “Tomorrow, we’ll get back to work supporting the BLM and helping them expedite their approval of this milestone.”

Also attending the Friday news conference were Colorado’s two U.S. senators, Michael Bennet and Mark Udall, state Rep. Bob Rankin, of Carbondale, and Garfield County Commissioner Tom Jankovsky.

“It is a compromise, but it is a positive for Garfield County in many ways,” Jankovsky said in a phone interview following the announcement. “It not just protects the more sensitive areas on the Roan; it allows some mineral production, as well.”

That’s good economic news for Garfield County and western Colorado, he said.

“Every rig that goes up, that’s 55 jobs, so it does have an impact,” Jankovsky said. “It also helps in terms of property taxes and everything that goes with that.”

Garfield County Commissioner Mike Samson, also reached by phone Friday following the announcement, said he remains hopeful that local communities will be held harmless for the reimbursed leases. Hickenlooper has promised to support a state budget resolution that would prevent future mineral lease and royalty payments to local governments from being withheld.

“I am hopeful that will be the case,” Samson said. “We must ensure that our local communities are held completely harmless, past, present and future.”

Samson was also clear in discussions with his fellow commissioners that he would not support the settlement if it prevented the canceled leases from being reissued at some point in the future.

“It’s important that these lands are not blocked from energy development in perpetuity,” he said.

Under the terms of the settlement, the BLM will cancel the stipulated leases and begin work to consider a management plan alternative to allow for limited development on remaining leases. While the deal precludes new leasing on top of the plateau under the anticipated 20-year life of that plan, new leasing could be considered once the plan expires.

Scot Woodall, CEO of Bill Barrett Corp., said the company is grateful to the BLM and elected officials for supporting an agreement that gets it out from under the disputed leases while allowing some new drilling to occur.

“The settlement ends a long period of uncertainty that has limited our ability to invest in development and to bring the Roan’s natural gas to market,” Woodall said. “We look forward to working with BLM as they complete the analysis necessary to start drilling.”

Last month, Bennet, Udall and Hickenlooper, all Democrats, joined Republican Tipton and Republican county commissioners from both Garfield and Mesa counties in urging Jewell to approve the settlement.

“Our local communities and the leaseholders have worked out this compromise,” Bennet said. “They’ve agreed to it because it balances a variety of needs and interests by allowing for some development while also establishing crucial environmental and wildlife safeguards.”

Tipton said the resulting compromise will allow “responsible energy production” to move forward.

“We worked to ensure that protections are in place to hold local communities harmless for any royalties that may need to be paid back,” Tipton said. “As a result, impacted communities, including Garfield and Mesa counties, voiced their support and helped push the agreement across the finish line.”

The settlement agreement was approved by the U.S. Department of Justice. It can be found on the BLM website at

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Aspen and Snowmass Village make the Aspen Times’ work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.