Affidavit: Argument about dog preceded double murder in El Jebel |

Affidavit: Argument about dog preceded double murder in El Jebel

Randy Wyrick
Vail Daily
Williams Anderson Amaya takes his seat for his first court hearing in Eagle. He faces two counts of first-degree murder in the shooting deaths of his aunt and uncle at their house in El Jebel in July.
Eleanor Nesbit / Vail Daily |

EAGLE — Williams Anderson Amaya might have intended to kill others, in addition to his aunt and uncle, Saturday night in a home at Sopris Village, the 5th Judicial district attorney said in court Monday.

Amaya purchased a .380 caliber handgun on the same day he allegedly killed El Jebel area residents Mayra Lorena Lopez, 40, and her husband, Eliseo Lopez, 42, according to authorities. The gunfire erupted after Amaya was arguing with Mayra Lopez about the family dog, according to an affidavit in support of an arrest warrant for Amaya.

There were seven other people in the house other than Amaya at the time of the slaying, according to the affidavit and an official with the Eagle County Sheriff’s Office. In addition to the Lopezes, there were their two sons, ages 14 and 13, as well as Amaya’s brother, Herbert Amaya and his wife and daughter, according to Jessie Mosher, public information officer for the Eagle County Sheriff’s Office.

One of the Lopez boys and Herbert Amaya’s family got out of the house from a bedroom after the gunshots. The other Lopez boy apparently stayed in the house during the argument, according to the affidavit.

“Other occupants appeared to be targeted during this event.”
Bruce Brown
5th Judicial District Attorney

Amaya, 33, made his first court appearance Monday morning after he was arrested early Sunday and booked on two first-degree murder charges. Amaya also will likely face attempted murder charges, District Attorney Bruce Brown said.

Amaya targeted other people in the house, so prosecutors are anticipating adding attempted murder to Amaya’s charges, Brown said.

“Other occupants appeared to be targeted during this event,” Brown said outside of the courtroom. “It appears that similar means used against the victims were contemplated to be used against others. Some of the forensic evidence indicated that.”

Amaya upset about family dog

The arrest warrant affidavit indicates that Amaya became agitated with the Lopezes and started arguing sometime around 11 p.m. Saturday in the home. The 13-year-old son of the Lopezes told detectives he was in his room preparing for bed when he heard Amaya yelling about the family dog. The boy said he heard a gunshot and heard Mayra Lopez yell for help, then there was another gunshot and she screamed in pain, the affidavit said.

Herbert Amaya, 31, the brother of Williams, was in his bedroom with his family when he was awoken by gunfire, according to the affidavit. Herbert told detectives he got out of bed and walked down a hallway and saw Mayra Lopez moving. Eliseo Lopez was just beyond her with blood around his head, the affidavit said.

The Lopezes’ other son, a 14-year-old, came running to Herbert and told him “to get his family and get out of the house,” according to the affidavit. Once they exited, the son called 911, according to authorities.

“This incident had the potential to be an escalated situation,” Mosher said.

When deputies arrived at the house, they conducted a protective sweep to make sure it was safe, according to the affidavit by Eagle County Sheriff’s Office Detective Aaron Veldheer. Another detective confirmed that the Lopezes were dead. The home was secured while a search warrant was sought. Officials also secured the arrest warrant.

Investigators contacted Williams Amaya’s cellphone provider and were able to trace him to his place of employment in Garfield County. They surrounded the building and he gave up without incident at 5:40 a.m. Sunday. Deputies said they recovered the handgun from Amaya’s car.

Williams Amaya had rented a room in his aunt and uncle’s house for about six months, the affidavit said. Herbert Amaya and his family had rented a bedroom in the house for about three years, according to the affidavit.

The dog survived the incident, according to Mosher. It was taken into custody and was scheduled to be returned to the family on Monday, she said.

Amaya represented by public defender

Dressed in orange jail clothes, Amaya rocked back and forth in his swivel chair during Monday’s court appearance. His brown eyes were wide as he looked around the courtroom from his seat at the defendant’s table.

His attorney, Reed Owens with the public defender’s office, sat beside him. Owens defended Rossi Moreau in one of Eagle County’s most recent homicide cases.

Brown and assistant district attorneys Joe Kirwan and Courtney Gilbert will prosecute the case.

In the courtroom, Amaya’s hands were cuffed in front of him, clasped to a thick leather belt around his waist. His feet were shackled with a 2-foot chrome chain. A court-appointed interpreter explained to Amaya in Spanish what was happening.

Amaya’s charges are expected to be made official by July 25. He is scheduled to be back in court at 9:30 a.m. on July 28.

In the meantime, District Court Judge Russell Granger ordered Amaya held without bail because he is considered a flight risk.

“He fled the scene immediately after the crimes were committed,” Brown said.

Amaya is a resident alien, in the country legally from El Salvador. He reportedly graduated from Aspen High School.

He has been employed locally for eight years, working with a pool and spa company, but has made several trips out of the state, Brown said.

The district attorney said he had no thoughts about Amaya’s thought processes at the time of the shootings.

Because it’s a capital offense, Amaya is eligible for the death penalty.

It will be “weeks, if not months” before it will be determined if the death penalty will be sought, Brown said.

Eagle County Coroner Kara Bettis said autopsies today will determine if the Lopezes were victims of single or multiple gunshots.